All Together Now: Who Hates "Sgt. Pepper"?
It's been ten years since Princess Di's death proved that yes, those stiff English upper lips can quiver with emotion. In today's Guardian, the UK's cultural elite (well, okay, a lot of them are American) open up and tell us how they really feel about the rock and roll canon.
http://music.guardian.co.uk/rock/story/0,,2102991,00.html
Ian Rankin loathes the first VU album! Luke Pritchard thinks "Pet Sounds" sucks! Franz Ferdinand disses "Marquee Moon!" ("You know when a boring guy is explaining to you the technical spec of a car, the fuel injection system and the leather seats, and his voice becomes so much background noise?") Joy Division's drummer doesn't like "Trout Mask Replica." (He said "it sounded like someone taking the piss," which I initially read as "sounded like someone taking a piss," which I thought was a better critique. Oh well.)
And obviously it's taken some people forty years to admit they were just pretending to like "A Day in the Life."
Gien Mr. Rankin's dismissal of "The Velvet Underground and Nico" ("'ermine furs adorn imperious.' Those are four words that should never appear in a rock song"), I thought I'd asked our guest blogger, Katherine Dunn, if there were any sacred cows she'd like to stick a tuning fork into.
As for the rest of you kids — no more beating on Kurt Cobain, okay? 'Cause he's already dead.
http://music.guardian.co.uk/rock/story/0,,2102991,00.html
Ian Rankin loathes the first VU album! Luke Pritchard thinks "Pet Sounds" sucks! Franz Ferdinand disses "Marquee Moon!" ("You know when a boring guy is explaining to you the technical spec of a car, the fuel injection system and the leather seats, and his voice becomes so much background noise?") Joy Division's drummer doesn't like "Trout Mask Replica." (He said "it sounded like someone taking the piss," which I initially read as "sounded like someone taking a piss," which I thought was a better critique. Oh well.)
And obviously it's taken some people forty years to admit they were just pretending to like "A Day in the Life."
Gien Mr. Rankin's dismissal of "The Velvet Underground and Nico" ("'ermine furs adorn imperious.' Those are four words that should never appear in a rock song"), I thought I'd asked our guest blogger, Katherine Dunn, if there were any sacred cows she'd like to stick a tuning fork into.
As for the rest of you kids — no more beating on Kurt Cobain, okay? 'Cause he's already dead.